Another Lawsuit Filed Against The Christian Baker – Isn’t This Harassment?

June 11, 2019
1838 Views

No case before the U.S. Supreme Court in October Term 2017 received more attention or raised more important issues than Masterpiece Cakeshop Ltd. v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission. The underlying issue is profoundly significant: Does a business have a constitutional right to discriminate based on its owner’s beliefs?

The lawsuit was from a same-sex couple who claimed that Phillips refused to bake their wedding cake for religous purposes. The Supreme Court ruled in favor of the baker’s religious rights and the case was dropped.

It was a victory for personal religious rights of small business owners. However, that victory was short-lived since a  trans-person who originally sought to sue the small business is back at it again. The trans person’s suit came shortly after the same-sex couple’s lawsuit.

CBS Denver reported that the attorneys for a Denver woman greased the pan for yet another legal battle against a Lakewood bakery already burned around the edges from a series of heated civil rights fights. Jack Phillips, owner of the Masterpiece Cakeshop, refused in 2012 to bake a wedding cake for Charlie Craig and David Mullins, a same-sex couple from Denver, on the basis of his religious beliefs.

Courthouse News:

“Three months after Colorado settled a discrimination case with the baker who refused to make a cake commemorating a gender transition, the transgender woman who was denied the cake sued the bakery herself.

In July 2017, Denver-based attorney Autumn Scardina asked Masterpiece Cakeshop owner Jack Phillips, a devout Christian, to bake her a cake. Phillips refused, according to Scardina’s lawsuit, because she is transgender.

In addition to violating her civil rights, Scardina claims the bakery falsely advertised “they would be happy to provide a variety of baked goods, including birthday cakes, to all members of the public, including LGBT individuals.”

The two-year-long lawsuit nearly ruined Phillip’s business because he was unable to operate while his business was in question. During that time Phillips drew his own lawsuit against the state and commission for showing what he said was anti-religious bias. Phillips later agreed to drop the suit since winning the Supreme Court case against him.

You may be interested

Snowflakes Eating Crow After Defending This Particular Illegal
The Scoop
5517 views
The Scoop
5517 views

Snowflakes Eating Crow After Defending This Particular Illegal

Jessica Hardy - June 15, 2019

I'll warn you now, this is a disturbing case where a plane-full of bleeding hearts defend a criminal without knowing…

Mike Pence Sets His Sights on Ilhan Omar and He’s Not Holding Anything Back!
The Scoop
9505 views
The Scoop
9505 views

Mike Pence Sets His Sights on Ilhan Omar and He’s Not Holding Anything Back!

Jessica Hardy - June 15, 2019

Whoever thought to put anti-Semitic Rep. Ilhan Omar on the House Foreign Affairs Committee should get their head examined. She…

Watch: Carter Page Says Mueller Reports Only Tells Half The Story
The Scoop
884 views
The Scoop
884 views

Watch: Carter Page Says Mueller Reports Only Tells Half The Story

Jessica Hardy - June 14, 2019

In the wake of the Mueller report, there have been growing scrutiny over edits and omissions in Mueller's findings.  Dems…