Lead Patriot

Right Leaning Commentary

Newsweek Headline Stirs Debate
The Scoop

Newsweek Headline Stirs Debate

Let’s dive into a recent media controversy that’s been stirring up quite a bit of discussion online. It all revolves around a Newsweek headline and how it’s framing Republican support for a tax proposal by Vice President Kamala Harris—a proposal that originally came from former President Donald Trump. Now, this might sound like a simple story, but there’s a lot more going on here, and it’s got people talking about media bias and accuracy.

So, what’s the story? Newsweek published an article titled, "Kamala Harris' Tax Proposal Backed by Majority of Republicans." At first glance, this headline suggests that Harris has managed to win over a good chunk of the Republican base with her plan to ban taxes on tips for service and hospitality workers. But here’s the catch—the headline doesn’t tell the whole story.

When you dig into the article, you find out that the support for this policy was actually measured before Harris even announced her backing of it. In fact, the poll referenced was conducted on July 29, well before Harris made any public statements on the matter. Not only that, but the policy was first introduced by Donald Trump back in June and had already been added to the Republican platform.

As you can imagine, this discrepancy between the headline and the article’s content sparked a wave of criticism online. Many users on X (formerly Twitter) were quick to call out what they saw as a misleading narrative. Reporters and politicians alike chimed in, pointing out that the proposal was originally Trump’s idea and accusing Newsweek of trying to spin it as a win for Harris.

One notable comment came from The Spectator reporter Matthew Foldi, who stated, “That’s because it’s Donald Trump’s tax proposal.” Iowa State Rep. Carter Nordman echoed this sentiment, saying, “That’s because it’s literally @realDonaldTrump’s tax proposal…”

Others, like Rick Scott’s communications director McKinley Lewis, were even more blunt, labeling the headline as “an insane take” for trying to attribute Trump’s policy to Harris.

To add fuel to the fire, Trump himself didn’t hold back. He took to Truth Social to accuse Harris of copying his plan, coining the hashtag #CopyCatKamala. He claimed that Harris’s move was purely political and that she wouldn’t actually follow through with the policy. His campaign quickly jumped on this narrative, emphasizing that the proposal was a “TRUMP idea.”

Written by Arthur Higgens - August 13, 2024